Tuesday, July 15, 2014

John Dewey: An Ideal Educational Culture

Throughout my undergraduate career, I contemplated my prospects as a teacher, and whether or not I'd be able to create the positive classroom environment I believe students deserve, but are rarely provided. I wavered in belief of my capability to balance personal connection with educational enrichment, and to be able to be "on" everyday to affect students in a positive way. John Dewey's article, My Pedagogic Creed, sheds light on many of the ideals and thoughts that led me to continue my pursuit of a career in education, although throughout much of it I couldn't help but feel it was an idealistic picture, like the one I had painted in the past, but more recently have become aware is not entirely true.

 In the article, Dewey delves into his beliefs about the various layers of education, describing his ideas of education, of school, of subject matter, the nature of method, and school and social progress. He presents various ideals a school and the community involved in a school should uphold, from the community's investment in a student and vice versa, to building autonomy within students, to a teacher's role which shouldn't be as an authoritarian, but rather as a medium to aid students in seeking knowledge, to how to enact forms of discipline, and more. While they were all incredibly important and very legitimate ideals regarding the structure of a student's education, I definitely felt that in this day and age, with all the struggle and back and forth between policy makers, administrators, parents, teachers, and others invested in the state of education, and felt a little hopeless in some of the ideas put forth by Dewey. One idea in contrast that I feel definitely is a possibility and I think a must within all classrooms, an idea that Dewey came back to time and again, was that of making the student's education part of a larger social development, built upon making their education relevant and applicable.

"  I believe that knowledge of social conditions, of the present state of civilization, is necessary in order to properly interpret the child's powers. The child has his own instincts and tendencies, but we do not know what these mean until we can translate them into their social equivalents. " Technology plays a frequent role in the lives of students, and to neglect it in education entirely i think would be unwise as it neglects the "present state of civilization" as Dewey puts it. Although technology can become quite a distraction, we can recognize some new ways that we can connect students with the content we are teaching.

Relevancy of content and connecting things with the society we currently inhabit is an essential element of a successful curriculum, and it is necessary for teachers to reflect on how the education they are transmitting is relatable to students and their situations.

4 comments:

  1. I was intrigued about Dewey's statement that technology plays a frequent role in the lives of students, and to neglect it in education entirely I think would be unwise as it neglects the present state of civilization. I wonder what he would say about technology in today's society and how it impacts student learning. I would imagine that he would strongly support high tech classrooms and BYOD for students. Would Dewey see today's technology as helping with the socializing of students into society?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kareem,
    Reconciling students' interests with education is no doubt a daunting task. Combining the two is an area in which I also question my ability. Will I be able to engage students by connecting what they like with lessons? Not always, but I will try.

    You also seemed at the end of your second paragraph to be reaching the cusp of another topic: social life. The phrase is ubiquitous in Dewey's theory, yet it always seems just out of reach. I've been trying to decipher what exactly he means as it is the focal point of his efforts.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm just going to pluck one idea out of your thoughtful post, Kareem; the idea of nurturing student autonomy. My feeling is that if you focus serious attention on this matter, whatever the content is that you teach, you seek to shape experiences that help students develop autonomy and a greater sense of agency, you are more than halfway home. Whether it is your mentor, your colleagues, the other teachers in your building...observe how this happens and ask about it. I'm not saying that it is always easy to access this, but keeping this goal in the forefront of your consciousness (and on your "observational agenda") will make a huge difference.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very cool, Kareem!

    I challenge you to consider a different perspective on the "balance between personal connection and educational enrichment".

    Dewey discusses how without a social context, education is meaningless. That it is important to have students interpret what they have learned, socially.

    Imagine personal connection and educational enrichment not as competing interests, but as integral to furthering one another. How might this change your perspective entering the classroom, if this were to be true?

    ReplyDelete